Author: Carmel Guilfoyle

  • Increasing Citizen Awareness and Engagement

    Increasing Citizen Awareness and Engagement

     

    Citizen-Awareness-and-Engagement.jpg

     

    In recent years, we’ve seen more people than ever before all around the world standing up for what they believe in and becoming involved in politics and government. While this can sometimes be seen as negative because it’s associated with violent protests, unnecessary deaths, and rebellion, there are numerous benefits to political involvement and engagement.

    Often it can feel like we may have nothing in common with someone who lives thousands of miles away from us, speaks a different language and lives in a foreign country. But in reality, there are so many experiences we all share, both good and bad.

    For example, in the last few years, there have been multiple movements, including the Women’s Rights Marches and BLM movement, that originated in the United States and led to protests and gatherings around the world. While the direct root of these movements, Donald Trump’s anti-women and sexist history and comments and the killing of George Floyd were specific to the United States or even a particular city within the country, the more significant issues, sexism, racism, and police brutality, are all things that people around the world have experienced and feel strongly about. Both movements have seen thousands of events worldwide, with millions of people gathering to show their support and make their voices heard and have led to changes being made by governments around the world.

    These movements also help to educate individuals on issues happening around the world. Take, for example, the recent anti-government, pro-democracy protests in Hong Kong. The issue at the root of these protests goes back almost 40 years to 1984 when Britain and China came to an agreement that would return Hong Kong, which was a British colony at the time, to China in 1997. The treaty outlined that while Hong Kong and China would be one country, there would be two systems giving Hong Kong its own legal system, borders, and rights. In 2019, China introduced a bill that would allow criminals in Hong Kong to be extradited to China, where they would face much harsher sentences and treatment. In response, there was a sit-in at government headquarters, and the protests became increasingly violent as they went on but also gained media attention around the world. Without this media attention, many people in other parts of the world had no idea about Hong Kong’s history or the issues they were facing.  

    It’s often said that the more people that participate in a democracy, the more democratic it becomes, and these specific events directly show that this statement is true. As a result of these protests, bills were dropped, legislation changed, and new officials elected to name only a few changes. By becoming more engaged and socially aware, populations are forcing their governments to change from ones that represent only a fraction of the population to ones that actually represent everyone. As a result, governments are getting closer to achieving their intended purpose of protecting, supporting, and representing all citizens for the first time in history.

    The Public Consultation Institute of Ireland (PCII) is committed to engaging citizens and empowering communities through the use of emerging technologies, which are transforming how the Government and citizens communicate and interact. PCII’s mission is to bring more people into the public participatory process. Not only will this expand informed public engagement, early studies suggest that it is likely to enhance the diversity and quality of partipartipation. View a list of public consultations currently open at www.publicconsultation.ie

  • Engaging citizens through technology

    Engaging citizens through technology

    Public-Consultation-Institute-of-Ireland-Engaging-citizens-through-technology_RP_18june21.jpg

    The public sector could greatly benefit from employing new and innovative technology to better interact with local citizens. Although public consultation through forums, workshops and focus groups have always shaped policy, technologies like community engagement apps, the internet of things (IoT) and immersive technologies are a new and effective way for governments and public bodies to build trust with the local community. 

    Smart devices are becoming cheaper and more accessible every day. According to Ofcom, more than 96 percent of under 35s have access to the internet, and 93 percent of Irish households own a smartphone. By using these devices to increase two-way engagement with the local population, public bodies give citizens a way to be heard regardless of their position in the community. Considering the views of private citizens has always been a prevalent concern for public institutions, and feeling unheard or ignored is perhaps the most common complaint citizens have with policymakers. Too often, this complaint is entirely fair. Politicians have frequently overruled the wishes of local people in favour of policies that benefit a small group throughout history.

    There are so many benefits to listening to and actively engaging with the local community, rather than considering them to be a logistical problem that policymakers have to overcome.  Government is a public function and as such, it requires consistent public input to ensure dynamic, fair and representative policy-making.  For example, the government can become better informed about citizen’s pressing issues and spend public money in a more targeted fashion. Community engagement apps can poll citizens on any size issue and as frequently as is required in matters like budget surpluses and long-term planning related to infrastructure, schools and healthcare.

    Ireland-based organisations helping public bodies better engage with its residents are Public Participation Networks (PPN), which was set up in 2016 by the Department of Community and Rural Development to involve communities in the decisions being made by local authorities; PLACEengage, a digital placemaking platform that empowers people to voice their opinions and concerns about proposed urban and rural planning matters from the comfort of their homes through a virtual town hall; and ChangeX, which gets proven ideas and funding directly to anyone ready to lead impactful projects in their communities.

    The London borough of Newham recently used the CitizenLab platform to consult local people, businesses and shoppers on urban planning decisions, to great success. The engagement team analysed feedback from the local community and found that public art, wellbeing workshops and affordable local workspaces were among the most sought after projects. 

    This kind of community engagement helps keep politicians accountable. Platforms like PLACEengage and CitizenLab provide masses of data that politicians are obliged to use when deciding policy. When people feel their government listens to them, they are more inclined to trust policymakers, which further increases community engagement and improves the relationship between institutions and citizens.

    Catapult is another organisation helping public bodies generate two-way communication with local people through gamification rather than polls and surveys. The company develops games where residents decide on planning and spending for cities like London. People can choose how much to spend on all the services the government provides over a twenty-year period. Once enough people have contributed, the data is presented to policymakers to assist their decision-making process.

    Digital consultations like these build trust between public bodies and citizens and provide valuable proof for policymakers that their decisions are backed by the general public. Citizens can trace urban planning and budget decisions back to the source, which significantly strengthens democracy by granting citizens the policymaking transparency they desire. Covid-19 has accelerated digital adoption across the broader Irish population at a pace much faster than might otherwise  have been expected. This opens up an opportunity for organisations to engage with a wider range of the population in a smarter, fairer and more successful way.

     

    The Public Consultation Institute of Ireland (PCII) is committed to engaging citizens and empowering communities through the use of emerging technologies, which are transforming how the Government and citizens communicate and interact. PCII’s mission is to bring more people into the public participatory process. Not only will this expand informed public engagement, early studies suggest that it is likely to enhance the diversity and quality of partipartipation. View a list of public consultations currently open at www.publicconsultation.ie

  • Will the YIMBY Movement Impact Ireland

    Will the YIMBY Movement Impact Ireland

     

    YIMBY.jpg

     

    Guest post from https://placeengage.com  

    YIMBY, or ‘Yes, In My Back Yard’, is a growing movement that counters the increasing instances of NIMBY-ism or ‘Not In My Back Yard’, that is frustrating the delivery of vital new homes and infrastructure in towns and cities across the world. One of the main challenges of NIMBY-ism is that those responsible generally do not see their objections as this. They simply want to retain the status quo for their neighbourhood and instead, they talk about the inadequate infrastructure or amenities to support additional housing.

    This type of exclusionary objections to development tends to occur in wealthier, suburban areas where residents are motivated to halt any further development. Unfortunately, this is why we still have underused space and brown/greenfield potential development lands remaining undeveloped in areas where there is a demonstrable housing need. By contrast, the YIMBY movement is pro-development and actively encourages the right new development, in the right areas, based on empirical demand/ needs assessments of the current and future population.

    YIMBY is being driven primarily by the younger generation who have been locked out of affordable housing and  who face huge hurdles in owning their own homes.  They understand that the only way to address the lack of affordability in cities is to develop new homes across all types and tenures, for both renters and buyers.

     

    How the YIMBY movement is changing the market

    Unfortunately, every young adult today knows how challenging it is to get their first steps onto the housing ladder. But it is not just about home buyers, renters are sharing homes beyond the age or stage where this ought to be necessary. While many will likely opt out of the traditional home ownership in favour of a new model of shared accommodation, this is not an option for the majority of people when they wish to own their own home. And that is why YIMBY supporters from the US to the UK are shaking up the property market, lobbying housing developers and politicians with innovative ideas about how to increase supply and lower costs.

    First appearing in San Francisco in response to the lack of affordable housing, the movement has steadily grown around the world. Dublin, in particular, has become a key hub of YIMBY supporters in recent years. As thousands of skilled tech workers flocked to the city, it quickly became apparent that there were not enough homes to support the demand, seeing a shortage of accommodation and sky-high rents.

     

    How will YIMBY impact Ireland?

    As YIMBY supporters continue to grow, it is placing increased pressure on policy-makers to shake up their current approach to housing delivery. By turning these existing development practices on their head, it will create an exciting new future with affordable and quality housing for all.

    While new developments can be a temporary inconvenience for existing residents, bring real fear and uncertainty,  YIMBY is about showcasing the benefits that these new developments can bring to the entire community. With the housing shortage only set to worsen, the market needs a major shakeup, and the ‘Yes, In My Back Yard’ movement could be the much-needed change to transform the industry in Ireland but this starts with empathy, transparency, meaningful placemaking and a data-driven approach to community needs. 

    The Public Consultation Institute of Ireland (PCII) is committed to engaging citizens and empowering communities through the use of emerging technologies, which are transforming how the Government and citizens communicate and interact. PCII’s mission is to bring more people into the public participatory process. Not only will this expand informed public engagement, early studies suggest that it is likely to enhance the diversity and quality of partipartipation. View a list of public consultations currently open at www.publicconsultation.ie

  • Unprecedented public engagement in N/M20 Cork to Limerick virtual town hall

    Unprecedented public engagement in N/M20 Cork to Limerick virtual town hall

    NM20-Virtual-Consultation-Room-2.jpg

    Public consultation and community/stakeholder engagement has been transformed through the use of digital placemaking tools and virtual town hall events over the past 15 months as a result of pandemic and restrictions on in-person events.

    According to the Limerick Post newspaper, that has been ‘Unprecedented Public Engagement on N/M20 Cork to Limerick virtual consultation’. You can read more about here:

    https://www.limerickpost.ie/2021/06/14/unprecedented-public-engagement-on-n-m20-cork-to-limerick-virtual-consultation/

    The public consultation process for this critical Cork/Limerick project and the proposed routes resulted in an astonishing 40,000 interactions, both online and through the N/M20 Project Office. While the use of a virtual town hall was first developed back in 2018, using immersive technologies including virtual reality and augmented reality, its use for the statutory public consultation process for planning in Ireland is a relatively new phenomenon, aided by the outbreak of Covid-19.

    While the project’s virtual consultation room was supported by online and telephone consultation meetings, and feedback channels via email, the project website and post, there was some criticism of ‘digital lockout’ for members of the community without access to smartphones or reasonable broadband services.

    In an interview with the Limerick Post, Project Coordinator Jari Howard said “By any criterion, this was a very significant and successful public consultation. Notwithstanding the use of a format that would have been new to many people, there was a tremendous level of constructive engagement… The online format of the consultation has led to much higher levels of public engagement than normally experienced and these new methods will become an integral part of all future consultations for this project, along with the traditional public display events and physical meetings once the public health guidance permits same”.

     

    The Public Consultation Institute of Ireland (PCII) is committed to engaging citizens and empowering communities through the use of emerging technologies, which are transforming how the Government and citizens communicate and interact. PCII’s mission is to bring more people into the public participatory process. Not only will this expand informed public engagement, early studies suggest that it is likely to enhance the diversity and quality of partipartipation. View a list of public consultations currently open at www.publicconsultation.ie